(0:00) I know you have a good one, you try, I don’t believe a thing, I know you lie, all night long. (0:09) But you mean that change, I’m saying the same, had me losing my mind. (0:17) You said the city was mine.
(0:20) I ain’t never been the same. (0:22) I ain’t never been the one. (0:24) I ain’t never been the one.
(0:27) I don’t know what you want, just I wanna be there. (0:30) Some day a million dollar baby. (0:33) I ain’t never been the same.
(0:36) I ain’t never been the one. (0:40) I don’t know what you want, just I wanna be there. (0:44) Some day a million dollar baby.
(0:47) Hey! (0:48) That’s Christy Lucas. (0:50) I can see you dancing. (0:52) Welcome, everyone.
(0:53)Â listen, this is going to be the latest conference ever. People Leader 2024. Okay.
Thank you (0:59) all. What an incredible day. I’ve been at every session, taking notes, learning, and (1:05) now I am so excited.
If you are in the chat, listen, you just, I don’t even know if you’re (1:10) going to handle the power that we’re about to embark on right now with these phenomenal, (1:16) phenomenal thought leaders in this space. So let’s just get started. Thank you.
Please (1:20) be in the chat. We want to hear what you have to say. Go to the question and answer tab (1:25) if you want your question to be displayed on the screen.
So make sure. Well, let’s get (1:29) started because I have a dynamic panel. I’m going to let each one of our panelists tell (1:32) us a little bit about themselves.
We’ll start with April, go to Brenda and let Rachel round (1:37) us out. So April, tell us a little bit about you and your passion for this DE&I space. (1:41) Oh, thank you, Leesa.
And I’m so honored to be here. I’m trying to stop moving underneath (1:46) the table. I am April Allen and I am a consultant and a principal founder of Allen & Unger Consulting.
(2:01)Â And what we do is we do DE&I work. We do strategies. We do conflict intervention and equity interventions.
(2:08)Â We do coaching. We do training. We do all the things in the DE&I space.
And I do that (2:15) with my lovely partner, Shauna Unger. And I’ve been in this space for years, for the (2:22) majority of my career. I come out of Silicon Valley.
I’m currently in the Pacific Northwest. (2:28) And I love what I do. And I’ll stop there.
I tell you, it was exuding. It was exuding. (2:33) So thank you so much, April.
Turn it over to Brenda. (2:38) Yes. Good afternoon, everyone.
My name is Brenda Clegg. I am the Equity Community Engagement (2:44) and EEO officer in Chatham County, North Carolina. I have been doing this work for over 13 years (2:55) when DE&I was not the name.
And I am passionate about it. I believe that it’s something that has (3:04) to be continuous. I’m also a certified diversity executive and a member of the Society for Human (3:11) Resource Management.
Love that. I love you said certified. (3:16) That’s great.
Thank you, Brenda, for sharing and being here. And then we will turn it over (3:20) to the lovely Rachel Williams. Tell us a little bit about yourself.
(3:24)Â Thanks, Leesa Askew. Excited to be here. Excited to be here, everyone.
Good afternoon. I’m Rachel (3:32) Williams. I am the Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer for The Motley Fool, a financial advice (3:37) company.
Previously, I’ve been an inaugural head of DEI at companies like Google, Yelp and StubHub. (3:49) Amazing. As you can see, we are here to give you some epic, epic strategies for DE&I for 2025.
(3:57) But before we go into strategy, let’s just talk about how did we get here in the first place? (4:02) I don’t know, April, if you want to tackle first for us, like, you know, there’s a lot of (4:07) reversity. There’s been a lot of backlash over the last couple of years. How did we even get here? (4:14) Why is DE&I even up for conversation, right? Because most of us feel like it should be table (4:20) stakes, right? There should be no question.
No, that’s a good question. And you’re right. (4:25) Like, why are we even having so much? Let’s just call it what it is about backlash against DEI.
(4:30) You have folks that are nervous. What can I do? What can I not do? And I know, (4:33) you know, I’m a lawyer by trade. And so I often get the legal issues that we may get into a little (4:39) bit later.
But we’ve gotten here in some ways, if I’m being frank, that some of our efforts (4:47) have not always been ones that have been allowed for inclusivity, true inclusivity, as far as, (4:56) hey, what is this going to look like for everyone in the organization? Now, (4:59) we can talk about the social backlash and we have, you know, the political backlash with folks (5:04) who are just want to be mad about something. Really, some folks have just much to do about (5:08) nothing. We could talk about the financial backlash where folks are like, well, where (5:12) can we start pulling money? And we can talk about, again, the legal backlash and what is, (5:18) how does this apply or does this even apply to organizations outside of the education round? (5:23) But a lot of, you know, there is some fair criticism around DEI, I believe.
This is my (5:28) opinion. I won’t speak for the panelists around how do we do this in a way that brings everyone (5:33) along on the journey where folks, you know, to the point, exclusion is not inclusion. (5:39) And how do we get as much, as many champions, excuse me, around the organization as possible (5:45) understanding the business case behind DEI? As you just said, it seems like it’d be obvious, but (5:50) there is a real business case around DEI.
You’re more productive. You grow more market shares. (5:57) All the things that we can talk about here, and I’m sure we’ll get into, (6:00) but I think that is one of the challenges of how we’ve gotten here.
(6:05) Thank you so much, April. Powerful words. And I’m going to flip to Brenda and tell us a little bit (6:10) about, from your lens, how we got here.
I know you have, just for full disclosure, everyone, (6:14) Brenda and I are on the East Coast of the country, more in the Southeast. Brenda’s in North Carolina, (6:20) I’m in Florida. And I will say, I felt like on our side of the country, we were not as progressive (6:28) as the side where April and Rachel are residing on our West Coast.
But I think just talking to you (6:34) all, it’s all the same. So Brenda, tell us from your lens, how do you feel like we got here? (6:39) So I definitely agree with you, Leesa. Our side of the country, at least on the Southeast, (6:44) is not quite as progressive as the West Coast.
However, we are doing good things. (6:52) I think that DEI has become a scapegoat. We left a loophole, when I say we, those of us that are (7:01) educators, that are strategists for this work, we’ve left a loophole open for people to (7:09) misinterpret.
So in my viewpoint, this is a great time for us to now sort of recalibrate (7:17) DEI and start to really take the time to have those courageous civil conversations about what (7:26) it really means, and to take the time to explain what each word truly means, given real life (7:34) examples, so that people can get a better understanding. And knowing that it’s inclusive (7:42) of everyone. Our intention is not to exclude anyone.
It’s not inclusive if we leave anyone (7:49) out. So that’s one thing that we want to make sure that we say, while we are focusing on making (7:57) sure that everyone understands, that not everyone starts from the same point. And that some people (8:03) need a little bit extra of something, okay, but it doesn’t mean we necessarily have to take it (8:09) from someone else for them to get it.
And that’s been one of those loopholes. (8:14) Brenda, when you said that, with such conviction, I was looking for my loophole to fill it in, (8:18) because I have that accountability. And that is definitely, it starts with you.
Are you doing (8:25) everything you say you’re going to do, the loophole? So wow, wow, powerful, powerful, (8:29) that recalibration. And real quick, I just want to acknowledge Sophia’s comment. She said, (8:34) thank you for starting with the backlash.
We weren’t playing with you all today in the chat, (8:37) as we said. She said she believes that it’s an essential part of business. DEI also must shift (8:46) and transform.
And that is what is happening right now. So thank you, Sophia, for that. And (8:50) please continue with the chat.
And Rachel, tell us, look, look, my notepad is already on fire. (8:56) What you got for us? Well, nothing different than my fellow panelists. I mean, I agree with April (9:02) and Brenda that this is an opportunity for us to look at the ecosystem of this work in its totality (9:08) and to evaluate where we may have made some misses in the last decade or so.
(9:14) Since you brought up the East Coast, West Coast beef, you know, the biggie in two parts, (9:19) I’m going to lean, I’m going to lean in there. And I’m going to say being born and raised in (9:25) Silicon Valley and working for Silicon Valley tech companies, you know, Reverend Jesse Jackson (9:30) started this work over a decade ago. He I thank him all the time because he is the one that made (9:35) the call to action by showing up to Google shareholder meetings and challenging them (9:39) around their diversity numbers.
The challenge, I always tell him, with that call to action is that (9:47) it wasn’t complete in its ask. Right. And now we are we are seeing what happens when you don’t (9:53) make a complete ask and have a complete strategy.
His strategy or his ask was around diversity and (9:58) representation only. Right. Wasn’t around the pieces around equity.
It wasn’t around the pieces (10:03) of inclusion. And so now we are seeing where we missed and all of us here, I know, want to get (10:09) this work right. And so the next year or so should be us reframing the work and recalibrating.
(10:15)Â Oh, I love it. Recalibration, reframing, loopholes. Yes.
All for it. And the chat’s all for it, too. (10:24) And speaking of which, you know, with that cultural backlash, you know, the pendulum swung (10:28) so far.
Right. For some individuals, I love that all of you said we don’t want anyone to feel (10:34) excluded. Inclusion is not about exclusion.
Every single person needs to feel included. Right. (10:40) So because it’s swung so far for underrepresented groups and then people who started feeling (10:46) really excluded, how do you create an environment that you can justify investment in DEI with all (10:53) this corporate austerity and people feeling like they’re excluded when it comes to DEI efforts? (10:59) Let’s start with you, Rachel.
Brenda, let you weigh in and then we’ll let you round us out, April. (11:05) Well, I think I think number one is we need to understand that everybody has a role to play. (11:09) And I think, April, you alluded to that.
It is not just on the folks who are underrepresented. (11:14) It is not just the work of women. It is not just the work of the DEI leader, which is why usually (11:19) I try to keep my team kind of smallsies because I want I don’t want anyone to think that the DEI (11:26) team can handle it all.
I want everyone to figure out within their particular position in the (11:32) company. How is it that you can contribute to the strategy that I have brought forward? Right. (11:37) And so I’ll give you an example.
When I was at Google, I was working at Google X, which is the (11:43) innovation lab to Alphabet. So, you know, those driverless cars that people are wild for came out (11:48) of that organization. Yeah, I know.
And I was meeting with the legal team. I do my round with (11:58) all of the teams and all the departments and kind of encouraging and inspiring them to think of (12:02) their own strategies for their team. And the legal team came back to me.
Their idea was, (12:08) hey, we file patents here. We know historically patents have excluded certain people, certain (12:14) groups, certain communities from even being able to file or have their names added to them. (12:19) So we want to do our part when we’re filing patents for these new technologies that we are including (12:26) every underrepresented person who is on the team, every woman that is on the team so that their (12:30) names can be added to a patent.
Now, that’s real impact. I personally would not have come up with. (12:38) Right.
But it was my encouragement, my vision, my like empowering them and making an offering, (12:45) right, an offering for them to join me in this work that they came up with that brilliant idea. (12:49) So that is my takeaway for everybody. And as you’re doing this work is to think about where (12:55) you are in the organization, what you do have control and power over, how you can turn that (13:00) into some action for DEI.
Love that Rachel, love that so much. And especially with the patent, (13:08) right? Just a little tease and that’s forever. So yes, right.
Brenda, help us weigh in on what you (13:15) think, how that investment can happen, how you can make that basis for the investment for more (13:22) DEI, especially with the environment we’re in right now. Sure. Well, one of the things we have to (13:27) understand is, you know, everyone has to be included.
So what do you do? You have to let (13:34) everyone know, very similar to what Rachel said, right? We can drive the train with the conductors, (13:41) but we’re not actually moving it, OK? The work has to be done by every employee. So we have to give (13:49) them ownership of that. That means that we have to let them know that you have a role and that (13:56) every day you have to come to work with the intentionality to do the work, to include someone, (14:04) to ask someone, to be an ally, OK? And that we want everyone’s opinion, that no one should feel (14:13) left out.
So it’s something that we do, that we do intentionally. And we have the conversations, (14:20) you know, we use, you know, the Emtrain platform, for instance. We use that on a regular basis to (14:26) make sure we’re not just checking the box, but we’re actually having those conversations (14:31) monthly.
It’ll stimulate something so that you will react or do something a little different. (14:37) So for us, the business case is seeing the different departments, the employees working together, (14:46) you know, engaging, collaborating even the more, and letting them know this is in your hand. So (14:53) you want an ERG? What ERG do you want? And let’s do it.
But I’m not going to be running the boat, (15:02) right, or manning it. You have to take charge and take ownership of it. (15:07) I love that, Brenda.
That’s so true. And everyone is, Janine Yancy, our founder, (15:13) she says this all the time on our town halls. We all need to be rowing in the same direction, (15:17) right? And I love that.
Everyone’s in the boat, so you’re not just sitting there and your oar (15:23) is resting. Get out and let’s row together. Or rowing in the wrong direction.
(15:29) Okay, we’re going forward and you’re going backward. You’re going lateral and we’re (15:34) trying to go horizontal. Like some dance moves, right? You all over the place.
(15:41) April, round us out on this. What are your thoughts about how to make the business case (15:47) and just make it more relevant again? Yeah, no, I love what my panelists said, (15:54) my fellow panelists, Rachel and Brenda, and they both are right. And I love that example with the (15:59) patents, Rachel, and just, you know, making sure that you remove that barrier or progress folks (16:05) and within the organization.
I feel the same way. You know, one thing that, you know, I was (16:09) just coaching a group of white leaders, very white male cisgender leaders yesterday over the last (16:16) two days. And one thing that was helpful for them to see was the business case again, right? Because (16:23) some folks thought, hey, the initial business case around D&I was just kind of, let’s just (16:28) call a spade a spade, kind of this NPR, liberal progressive.
Here we go. Here we go down. What’s (16:34) the shiny carrot this time that we’re playing with? And telling them, look, no, these numbers (16:40) were re-ran again in 2023 and even 2024 by Deloitte, by Boston, by McKinsey, these consulting (16:47) houses.
And it’s showing, no, this is true. Now, no matter how you feel about it, right? I tell (16:54) them the work may be politicized, but it’s not political, right? And saying, hey, this is actually (17:02) a strategic advantage. Look, if you want to sustain, retain, and to grow and innovate, (17:11) you are going to have to buy into the work of DEI.
Now, it may look different to you. It may, (17:18) the term, you may not love the terminology because of where you’re located in the United States. (17:24) However, this is really about being an employer of choice because employees say this is one of (17:31) the top three things they look at.
So if you want the best employees, you are going to have (17:37) to consider DEI. Even, I just saw a study that 25% decide if they’re going to go for a promotional (17:45) rate, a promotion within their organization, sorry, 25% of folks buy if there’s a DEI program (17:53) that’s functioning within the organization. So, you know, also putting on my lawyer hat, (17:59) EEOC claims are up by one third.
Like, okay, so you’re just going to lose money. At least the (18:05) average claim, the average claim, we’re not even talking about the big ones are about $10,000. (18:10) So you’re like, yeah, you’re like, let me sip my tea.
It is going to literally can sink an (18:16) organization and take away from that if it’s a small organization. If it’s a larger one, it’s (18:22) taking away resource and profit. And so you’re going, okay, let’s just be smart about this.
(18:29) Let’s get out of our heads and the terminologies and who said what and who you’re voting for. (18:37) The reality is the world is full of difference. And that’s something that my business partner, (18:42) I always tell folks, that’s what we told them yesterday, the world is different.
(18:46) So, you know, and sometimes that helps with, you know, when I’m in, look, I’m in the Pacific (18:50) Northwest. So it’s progressive and it’s white. Okay.
And so you go, okay, let me help you. (18:58) John and Andy, y’all are not the same just because you’re both white men. (19:02) You came from a rural experience.
You came from a city experience. You came from, you know, (19:08) it’s so having them really understand sometimes just saying the word different kind of postures (19:13) the conversation a little bit differently. And that’s not shying away from the words of diversity, (19:19) equity, inclusion, which I think are really important, but starting to peel back the layer (19:23) of what we’re saying is folks are different.
And now you have five different generations (19:27) in the workforce. So unless you think this is all about race and gender, (19:31) it’s actually about helping people get along within a workforce so you can be productive (19:37) and actually get your product or your service out to the most people and get the most market share. (19:42) Right.
So if you, if you, if you crouch it in those terms, and let’s just, you know, we are (19:48) in a capitalistic society. It does tend to move the ball forward or continue moving the ball. (19:57) Listen, you saw me sipping my tea.
Absolutely. You really brought the knowledge. And I also (20:02) wanted to bring out, cause I love what you said.
And thank you, Katrina. She said, (20:05) you know, DEI is not just race, not just gender, but DEI is also what you can’t see. (20:10) Yeah.
Neurodivergent individuals will take over the workforce. I know many of you have (20:16) young children, grandchildren, nieces, nephews, godkids, anyone in your community, (20:21) generation alpha, over 40% are, are taught to become neurodivergent. So when you talk about (20:28) having psychologically safe spaces where people feel seen and heard and you’re, you understand (20:33) how you process, right? How everything is different.
It is so important to have that space. (20:39) I’m also want to call out Reggie. Thank you.
He said, ownership is so important to drive results, (20:44) influencing culture and accountability. And Nicola, thank you. She asked about what (20:50) environment can measure effectiveness that we’re going to talk about in our, in our solutions.
(20:54) And then we also have Sophia says that we’ve been talking about culture or patterns as behavior (20:59) and reframing from the standards of race, food, religion. We need to understand how to maneuver (21:05) patterns in a productive way. Thank you so much, Chad.
All these nuggets that you’re putting in (21:10) But let’s get back to just some of the terminology around. Is that the problem? Do we just need to (21:17) say we’re all different? This is what it is, or what are your thoughts about that? I’m going to (21:22) come back over to you, Rachel. What are you thinking about terminology? Do we just need (21:27) to change the definition of tomato versus tomato? Or is that the song? I see you trying to get me (21:32) riled up because you know, about words, (21:54) talking to a gen Xer who had to look up things in an encyclopedia and Webster’s dictionary.
(22:03) I’m going to stray from believing that words matter and the definition of words matter. (22:09) And I get it. Like I I’m exhausted by having to use all these words or even the addition of new (22:16) terms.
When I started, it was just the D then it was D and I, and then it was D I B. And I’m like, (22:21) what is this B? Then it was D I B J. Okay, now we then it was D E I A J. Like, okay, (22:28) I get it. We’re all exhausted about that. Words are extremely important.
So really quickly, (22:34) diversity is the representation of your workforce, the human beings that work in your company. What (22:41) is their representation? But it’s not just that. It is not just about the hiring.
It is also about (22:45) what is the reputation of your manager workforce, your leadership team, and your board? And how are (22:50) we moving those people up and through your entire company? So that is the entire employee life cycle. (22:56) Then we got inclusion. And inclusion, as we’ve been spending a lot of time here, (23:00) is all about leveraging that diversity.
And I like to use the word leveraging because just, (23:07) I think it was Verna Myers from over at Netflix who said, you know, diversity is the party and (23:13) being invited isn’t to the dance. Okay, I messed it up, but you all get it. And just being invited (23:23) isn’t enough.
You have to actually leverage and tap into the brilliance of the diversity that (23:28) is expressed in your organization. Otherwise you won’t be able to innovate. So I always want to (23:33) talk about leveraging that diversity.
So that’s the inclusion. My favorite one on the D E I space (23:40) is equity. And equity is when you are systemically trying to change some of the policies, (23:46) the practices, the programs that exist in your company that actually make people behave a (23:53) certain way.
And I think when you change the policies and when you change your programs (23:59) and some of your practices, those are the guardrails by which people then start to behave. (24:05) And to me, that’s the lasting legacy I want to leave. As you mentioned about motherhood, (24:11) I’m not a mother.
I’m an auntie on my best day, hoping to be a bonus grandma or something at some (24:16) point, but my legacy is through my work and I want to leave companies better than I found it. (24:22) And the best way to do that is to look at some of the practices through equity, making sure that (24:27) your policies are serving all of your employees, which means you need to look at all of your data, (24:35) whether it’s through the Emtrain platform, culture and trap for whatever platforms you are (24:40) using to gauge engagement in your organization. You need to use that, slice that data by (24:48) several versions of demographics, not just race, not just gender, but generational and any other (24:55) type that you can get to see where you are missing the mark on some of your policies and (25:00) your practices for your employee base, and then get about the business of fixing it.
That’s the (25:04) quiet work that I think we all should be doing right now. Yes. Yes.
Okay. (25:18) On that, and Brenda and Ava, I’ll let you all weigh in too about, again, (25:22) is it just a matter of the semantics because people don’t like the word or whatnot? So (25:27) tell us what you think, Brenda, and then chat. I’m going to make sure I acknowledge everything (25:32) and we will have some solutions for you.
We appreciate all of your activity. Thank (25:36) you for sharing and being a part of this conversation. So I am not a fan of smokescreens.
(25:42)Â Okay. I’m not, I’m just put that out there. I’m not a fan of that.
So I believe we do the work (25:51) and do it civilly, right? Civilly. Do it respectfully, but do the work and don’t be shy (26:01) about the fact that the work needs to be done. Everyone wants to know the business case, (26:08) what’s in it for me, the with them, right? So you have to explain the with them.
If we do the work (26:17) and we’re not explaining what’s in it for them, then no one has a buy-in. Everyone’s afraid of (26:25) change and change is constant. It’s the only constant thing, right? It’s change, right? (26:31) So when we talk about diversity, we have to talk about, you know, draw the picture, (26:36) draw the big picture of the beautiful quilt, okay? And the fact that when you make a quilt, (26:42) when a quilt is made, it’s not made from one piece of fabric.
It’s made from many, (26:49) many different pieces, different colors, different patterns. And think of our people, (26:56) our employees as those different pieces coming together, woven together to be stronger (27:04) and warm, to actually have a purpose. So I draw the picture because so many times we (27:12) leave that little opening and we don’t do that.
So we have to be straight, I believe, (27:17) and we have to be straightforward. Inclusion, I think Rachel, you know, she said what inclusion (27:24) is. And the only thing that I would add to that is that we’re not, not only are we asking you to the (27:32) dance and we’re asking you, do you need anything to get to the dance? Do you need a ride to the (27:41) dance? Okay.
And then once you’re there, you know, do you need a ride home or what kind of music do (27:51) you like? I’m including you. I want to make sure that not only have I invited you, but I’m (27:57) taking into consideration the things that would make you feel most comfortable and to help you (28:05) be your authentic self. And we want everyone to have a chance to dance to their own music, (28:09) you know.
But we want to make sure that we don’t forget that portion. (28:17) And equity is definitely my favorite too. And I don’t believe that equity should ever be removed (28:23) from the word or from the phrasing.
Okay. We just need to take the time to explain it. (28:30) And we need to, as I said earlier, recalibrate, just take a stand back and explain it in a way (28:41) that people will understand why equity is so important.
And then measure it and have the (28:47) measurements, you know, whatever you’re using. If you don’t have your KPIs, if you don’t know (28:55) what you’re, how, you know, where you’re starting from and what you’re going to measure, (29:00) then how do you know what you’re doing? How do you know that you’re even (29:03) making a difference? So we have to be able to measure what we’re doing. (29:10) Okay.
You’re muted, Leesa. You’re muted, Leesa. You’re still muted.
(29:24)Â You are muted. It’s okay. I know I’m supposed to go, because you said right when I should go.
(29:34) So I will, because I know I’m supposed to go. So I will just, I will go. No, I, you know, what my, (29:41) what my esteemed colleagues on the floor said, you know, they have said, I agree with everything (29:47) they said.
I, you know, and Rachel, you were giving me the woo-woos. I wanted to get teary (29:52) eye about auntie and leaving legacy and within an organization and in the workforce. And, (29:59) and Brenda, you are, you are really the auntie right now.
Cause you said, well, (30:03) we’re not going to do is hide the word. Okay. So I’m like, all right, no.
And I, and I am with (30:12) both of my panelists. I agree. I mean, explaining the word, taking the time to explain it.
(30:19) Case in point yesterday, I was with the group. They were like, well, I don’t really, you know, (30:23) trying to understand equity better. And I’m like, let’s think about it as fairness.
We talked about (30:28) the GI bill, right? Well, we want to just treat everybody equally. Why don’t we just do equality? (30:33) Okay. Well, that was the first measure by the government to really say, you know what we’re (30:38) going to have, we’re going to pay black folk or folks of color serving in the, in our, (30:45) in our forces and white GI is the same.
Now we know the story of the GI bill came along. (30:51) The problem is they couldn’t use it equally, right? That’s where equity had to come in place. (30:55) You’ve given them the same amount, $5,000 or whatnot, and say, go, go to a college, (31:00) go to a university, um, and, and educate yourself or go get a house.
Well, you’re not able to do (31:06) that when folks are, have a restricted covenants and within their visa say, I’m not running to a (31:13) black person or a Negro, as they would say back then, or you have colleges that say, especially (31:18) a lot of those men, um, in the armed forces came from the South, the black men and said, Hey, (31:24) I’m not going to, uh, let you into our college. We, we don’t, we, we have a race based preference (31:31) for white folk. And so you can’t come into the college.
And so that is what the problem is when (31:36) I’m trying to explain, um, the difference between, well, when I get the folks say, why can’t we just (31:41) treat everyone equal? And why, and why is equity in there? Because that is what equity looked like (31:46) making, making sure that things are fair. Even when something, when there is someone’s qualified (31:52) to do the work, that was another discussion we had. I said, I don’t know where this misnomer, (31:56) this fallacy around folks are not qualified.
We’re saying, no, if they are qualified, (32:01) why are you making the work harder to do when you can do something to remove a barrier? (32:06) That is the, that is the discussion. Yes. We also talk about the ADA and American Disability Act, (32:13) right? We, in the eighties, folks could not benefit from, from sidewalks and curves.
Now (32:22) they can. Why? Because we were there to address the problem because there was legislation push (32:27) so that veterans mainly could go to work to buy a house because there weren’t elevators. There (32:35) weren’t escalators.
There weren’t of ADA friendly accommodations. Were they not qualified to do (32:41) the work? Yes, they were qualified. However, to Brenda’s point, I need, how am I going to get to (32:47) work? Right? How do I get to work? Are we making sure that I can get to work safely and my wheelchair (32:52) can fit into the elevator? Or there’s a place that I can, you know, roll up a ramp versus trying to, (32:59) trying to get upstairs.
And so when you, when you start explaining these examples to folks, like, (33:04) Hey, this is really what equity is. It’s about fairness. It’s not about unfairness is really (33:10) at its basics.
It has been, it’s helpful and it’s important. Now I would say when Rachel and I were (33:17) talking before, I had made a comment and I, and I’m already a fan of Rachel, but she made a comment (33:24) around, well, we’re going to keep these words because all of us have been on the Dewey Decimal (33:27) system in this group, right? We go to Webster’s and it’s a non-troubled school. You can write (33:34) that word 200 times and come back and turn it into the teacher.
I was a little bit of a rebel, (33:39) you know, but I was, so I know about Webster’s and all that. I think what I have seen as a (33:47) organization, one automotive, automotive space, engineering automotive space, one in healthcare (33:53) and what I, what sometimes was my challenge. I never want to take the words DEI out.
I don’t (33:59) know how Sherm, Sherm’s Society of Human Resources even made that suggestion or made that mandate. (34:07) We’re going to just go DNI, yes, if you’re T because you really can’t have inclusion (34:11) without equity. It doesn’t make sense to me.
You know, that’s, that’s my (34:17) position on that. But my, my point with saying all that is sometimes you get into (34:26) situations as a DEI practitioner, especially when you’re in the Pacific Northwest. (34:33) Folks want to police every word that’s being said.
Now you may not have this problem in the (34:39) Southeast as much as we do. I mean, they have read every book, watched every, listened to every (34:45) podcast, and then they want to be the teacher. So if you say one wrong word, let me correct you (34:51) in front of folks.
Well, how do, nobody wants to hear that. So I have seen that play out over (34:56) and over with white guys, white cisgender guys trying to lean in and say, let me, okay. And (35:02) they’re like, nope, that’s not the right word.
You said it wrong. You should be saying, and they’re (35:05) like, okay, I’m never talking again. So sometimes I find myself as somebody who also is a professor (35:12) as an adjunct professor, I’m like, wait a minute, this is not an academic exercise.
(35:17) This impacts real people’s lives. And so we’re not here to play the word policing game at every (35:24) junction and every term. What we want to do is make sure people understand the tangibility and (35:30) the reality of how this can impact you as a business and impact the people that are in your (35:36) organization.
They can go from thriving to thriving. If we, if you have a heart for the (35:42) work and understand the business acumen for the work as well. So that’s sometimes my only, (35:48) cause sometimes I’m like, I’m so exhausted by y’all trying to correct everybody’s language.
(35:51) We can’t get anything done. Cause y’all worried that they say the latest word. Well, I can’t (35:56) keep up with all the terms and I have devoted my life to this work for about 20 years now.
So (36:02) I’m like, there has to be grace is my point. There’s a term that my business partner, I use, (36:07) we call it grace space, safe space. I am inviting leaders into to say the thing that they’re (36:13) thinking that they know is not safe to say outside in this, this canceled culture we live in.
Right. (36:20) Listen, the chat is just loving this conversation. We have, we’re coming up on our time.
So what I (36:27) want to do, I have two questions in the chat. I’m gonna display them. If one of you want to (36:31) answer this first question, it says I’ve seen a trend of merging DE&I with ESG roles as a single (36:37) DE&I leader in a 3000 plus organization.
I can’t even imagine having to take that role. I’m curious (36:44) if you all think companies creating these hybrid roles are a red flag to avoid. Wow.
I’m going to (36:50) sip my tea on this one too. Someone wants to answer that. And then we have another question (36:54) that will lead us to our solution.
So, you know, thank you all. Who wants to tackle this question? (37:01) Um, I’ll take it since I’m internal, um, and a corporation. I look, things have been added to (37:08) this role for the last two decades.
Um, first starting with recruiting and then they, they (37:15) added, okay, you’re a part of, um, uh, kind of our, our employee retention, not just hiring, (37:21) but how do we keep them? Okay. So then, and then they decided to add, um, you know, (37:26) with all of the social crises, you need to help us with our comms and communication. (37:31) Um, okay.
These companies are innovating, they’re developing new products, things like AI, um, and (37:36) tracking faces. Well, we definitely need DE&I’s voice in that because, uh, the engineers are (37:41) missing some things because they, right. So, so it’s been expanded from, you know, (37:46) the beginning to the end, really.
So if you want to take on ESG and you can do it, here’s what I (37:53) think though, that you will need as a DE&I leader, anybody doing this work. And this is from my (37:57) friend, Arthur Chan. Look up Arthur Chan on LinkedIn.
You need authority, first of all. So (38:04) you need to make sure that you have the authority to do ESG, DE&I, and all of the work. Otherwise, (38:10) and you can have that discussion.
You need the power to make some decisions on DE&I, ESG, and (38:17) whole alphabet. Uh, you will need resources. So if they’re adding three more letters to the acronym, (38:24) that is your title, then you’re going to need three times the resources.
So if they’re willing (38:29) to do that, then great. And then you will need some protection because this work is risky and (38:35) dangerous and, um, challenging. And so you need your leaders to understand that things are going (38:41) to be a challenge and at times you will need their protection, their support, and their sponsorship.
(38:46) So if you have those four things, I say take it on all alone, baby. Then, you know, hire, (38:51) hire the rest of your team out to handle the ESG and to handle the DE&I and to do all the things. And (38:56) you set the strategy, the tone, and the vision.
That’s my suggestion. I’m here for it. But powerful.
(39:02)Â Get those four things. Those four things. There you all have it.
And the chat is loving it. Everyone (39:07) was agreeing that it’s exhausting. Um, and, and, and definitely gave some great advice.
And this is a great (39:13) segue, um, Mai-Mai Liu for putting this out there to get past the noise. What are your organizations (39:18) focused on for 2025 to move things along? So we’re not just talking about how others are talking (39:24) DE&I. This is powerful because we’re going to go into our solutions.
I know some things that we (39:29) discussed prior was just doing the quiet work. I know Rachel talked about that. Data-driven (39:35) decision-making, which Emtrain is happy to help any of you with your cultural skills.
We can get (39:39) into that. Inclusive leadership training, reframing DE&I, and building DE&I to everyday (39:44) practices. So I want to do a round-robin.
I’ll start with you, April, Brenda, and then Rachel. (39:49) Just what are your, what are the strategies? Let’s get to the meat and potatoes of this conversation. (39:55) Um, we’ll start with you, April.
Okay. Yeah. No, I, I was pausing for a moment and thinking because (40:00) you just said a lot, right? I’m, I, Brenda, you measure what matters, right? So first of all, (40:06) the KPIs and metrics, I want to make sure that there is a comprehensive strategy touching (40:10) all parts of the organization.
So I want to, whether that’s consumer engagement and whether (40:16) that is client experience, whether that is, you know, IT, every part of the organization, (40:22) because everyone can benefit from DE&I. And as we all stated here, and I like what Rachel said, (40:27) I keep my team small because a lot of times you hear people like, I, I don’t have enough people. (40:32) And she’s like, wait, first of all, none of us have had enough people to be honest, but it’s like, (40:38) but she also is now able to give ownership to the folks that need to take ownership.
Right. (40:44) So for me, that’s important. Something else that we’re seeing a lot is, you know, we’re getting (40:48) caught, we’re getting called in for a lot of equity conflict work, meaning interventions within (40:55) organizations with, and you know, what’s been surprising.
It hasn’t just been with, you know, (41:00) you may think MAGA versus Kamala, right? Like this kind of, you know, red blue camp, you know, (41:07) it’s not. What we’ve been getting called in is from DEI teams, ERGs, committees, DEI councils (41:14) and committees who are very entrenched in, this is how the work has to be done or not able to get (41:22) along. It’s also that scarcity mindset.
So I really like to, you know, advise organizations around (41:30) making sure that the groups that are supposed to be helping folks like Rachel and Brenda (41:37) are actually understanding their role and their contributions and making that very clear for them. (41:44) So they don’t get going off into the yonder and it’s not a chaos ball. That is, you know, (41:50) I found that to be one of the most distracting things.
And they’re like, I’m here for DEI, (41:54) but they’re not understanding business imperative and strategy. So making sure that that is very, (41:59) very clear so that you are moving together and in sync and what does that look like and what can (42:06) they own and what can they own and really help champion throughout the organization as well. (42:13) And making sure that these people have, folks have in your organization, the muscle for conflict.
(42:20) Because one thing we say is when you put folks that are different within a situation, (42:26) ultimately, you’re going to be better off. It’s worth it. However, you’re going to have conflict.
(42:32)Â That is the reality. I have been married for almost 20 years. I know I look like I’m 15.
(42:40) That means I got a good hook. But like I haven’t, you know, but we have conflict. Why? Because (42:49) we’re having real discussions and we are different.
And so, but what, and we have to be able to frame (42:55) those conversations or reframe them as this is good to not always agree. This is good to have (43:01) the difference of opinions at the table and make us pause and think and not just be so efficiency. (43:06) And, and we got to all play nice and get along.
Now, obviously you need to not be there to be (43:11) just disruptive, but actually welcoming that. And so that’s something that we, we take very (43:16) serious. And what I do is we go in and coach teams around.
Now we’re going to actually build a muscle (43:20) for disagreement and welcome that in. So you do have folks coming into the coming and not just (43:27) getting a chair and saying, Oh, make a seat at the table, but actually included it at the table (43:34) and not just sitting there. Right.
We got Thanksgiving coming up. Like if I bring (43:38) collard greens, I want you to eat my greens. I don’t want you to just be like, Oh, they’re over (43:42) on the table.
Nobody touched them. Like, I want you also to eat my food too and value what I’m (43:48) bringing to the table. So I, you know, those are, there’s a couple of things I would think (43:52) that organizations really are going to have to think about and that we’ve seen.
And again, (43:56) leadership competency, I think Emtrain does a wonderful job. When I was within my last (44:02) organization leading DEI efforts, I used Emtrain and that was so helpful because you’re embedding (44:08) these leadership competencies. Folks are seeing the real time with the data analytics, like, Oh, (44:14) yeah.
Okay. I think I’m good here, but I’m not because I’m not actually, (44:19) I’m actually not making the right decision. All right.
The one that’s not full of bias or full (44:24) of my, you know, of, of just my own lack of empathy because of my, you know, my rush decision. (44:29) And so I really, really strongly, you know, I love that also is great for interventions when you can (44:36) see a manager in there and you’re like, well, why can’t, why to the talking about metrics? Well, (44:44) why is there so much turnover among black and brown people? Or why is there so much turnover (44:48) among women on this team? Or why then you go in and you have those, you see that it’s like (44:54) segmented down from Emtrain and you go, okay, now we know either for any, that you’re going to have (44:59) to get some more skilled leadership competency skill sets, or we may need to just move you to (45:03) another place or move you out of the organization. If there’s something overtly there that is, (45:08) you know, egregious.
So that is, those are my thoughts around that. (45:12) No, thank you so much, April. And I know we’re coming at the top of our hour.
So Brenda, (45:16) and, and you use Emtrain. I know that you all, all of you have, tell us a little bit about what (45:22) you think are practical solutions that people can get involved with right now for their 2025 DEI (45:29) strategies. We’ll get your way.
And Rachel, then we have one last question. And we’re going to wrap (45:33) this up. This has been so much fun.
So Brenda, I’ll let you go. I’ll make it really quick. I think (45:38) that it’s important for us to stay on course.
Okay. So we’re continually to look at our policies, (45:45) our procedures, but more importantly, we, because we have to embed it in every aspect (45:51) of the county work that we do. Okay.
From every employee to our clients, our customers, (45:58) the community that we’re serving. But in order to also make sure that we’re thinking about it (46:03) and doing it intentionally, we’re using the platform. We’ll continue to do that on a monthly (46:10) basis, rolling out assignments to everyone.
So it’s a continual conversation. And then we’re also (46:18) asking departments to lead up your own courageous conversations and have those (46:24) courageous conversations. And to understand the conflict, it’s good as long as it’s respectful (46:31) and productive.
Okay. And then knowing when sometimes you just have to stop and say, we have (46:37) to stop and agree to disagree. But continually, our look at 2025 is to keep going, to continue doing (46:47) the education on a regular basis.
We’re not doing it on an annual, it’s a monthly conversation, (46:56) a monthly pattern of thinking about this, because you have to come to work a hundred percent of the (47:01) time, intentionally thinking about being inclusive, being, providing equity, being diverse (47:09) and welcoming it. Welcoming. I love that.
And I know we are being tight with our time, but Rachel, (47:16) please also weigh in this. Thank you so much, Brenda. But Rachel, if you could weigh in and (47:20) talk about when you talk to us about quiet work, I just love that term.
Yeah. You know, it’s, (47:26) it is not the fanfare of posting on the company’s LinkedIn page about your support for DEI. It is (47:33) not, you know, it is not the loud work we saw immediately following the death of George Floyd.
(47:40) That didn’t make change for the people who really needed it inside of your company. (47:43) The equity work is really the change that people need. And that is the auditing of your processes.
(47:49) So I know HR people are very attached to the things that they’ve built in terms of all of (47:54) the policies and things that support human beings. Like it’s working. I guarantee you, (47:59) it’s not working for everyone.
So I would just ask that you take a step back. And if you can’t (48:04) take a step back, hire a third party to take us, to take a look at your policies and your practices (48:09) for you to give you some, some ways that you can improve what that book from good to great. (48:15) We’re trying to get to great.
There you go. There you go. Oh, love it.
Love it. And we have one (48:20) final question that I wanted to put up on the chat. Do you have any advice around navigating (48:24) disagreements about the right way? What, how, who to engage with DEI and orgs where the buy-in is (48:31) there, but there are significant differences in ideas of how the work should happen.
What (48:37) priorities are. Brenda, you’re the first person that came to mind about this because I know the (48:42) dynamic of your organization and I’m telling you all follow every single one of these women on (48:48) LinkedIn. They’re incredible.
And Brenda, you definitely are doing a lot of courageous work (48:51) in that space. A lot of resistance was there. So yeah.
What’s some of the advice that you have? (48:57) I think that you, you have to start and, you know, they say, how do you eat an elephant? (49:02) Right. Small bites. Pieces at a time.
Okay. So you have to stop and focus on, (49:12) you know, you have to prioritize and focus on one thing at a time and work on that. (49:19) Look at policies, start with policies, look at hiring practices, you know, start there first.
(49:27) Okay. Talk about succession planning. Those are areas that you can start and that you can have (49:35) a positive impact.
What about onboarding? You know, we always think about what we’re doing, (49:41) you know, we get, we’re bringing in, we’re recruiting, we’ve got them in. How do we keep (49:45) them? Have we onboarded them correctly? Look at those onboarding, you know, are we communicating (49:52) what we do and how we do what we do? And are we asking them, you know, everyone learns (50:01) differently. Are we, are we asking, how do you learn or what’s your preference? How do you like (50:06) to be, how do you prefer to be communicated? Those are the things that we have to start doing (50:14) and make those priority when we’re looking at where do we go? How do we do this first? (50:19) Little pieces at a time.
Love it. Love it. Just one quick thing.
I just want to say, (50:27) because it also sounded like it was a little bit of a power dynamic between who is, who ultimately (50:31) decides what actions get taken. And what I will say is that while DEI leaders are here to co-create (50:38) solutions on behalf of all employees, it is up to the expert in the work. (50:44) So those of us who have been doing this deep work for what, what’s an expert? 10,000 plus hours? (50:51) Yeah.
Okay. So let’s lean on the experts in this work to understand kind of the ecosystem, (50:59) have done the studying, have read the research in order to make the decisions on kind of the (51:03) go forward. But yes, co-creation in your opinion, in your voice should matter.
(51:08) But I often feel like the tug of war wouldn’t happen in a marketing department. This tug of (51:12) war wouldn’t happen in a sales department because you would lean on that sales leader. (51:18) The same way, I think we should rely on the DEI experts.
(51:23) I love that Rachel. And the only thing I would add to that is, is that, you know, I’m always looking (51:29) at what, what problem can I solve? Right. So if you don’t, if I don’t have somebody who’s a strong, (51:36) you know, leader or even a champion in the C-suite, I mean, you, you really do need that.
But (51:42) when I’m trying to get them to, to lead and say, well, this is the problem I can help solve. Right. (51:48) So it is really about being strategic in that sense.
What problem can we solve? Like what is a, (51:55) I’m working with the organization now, they’re trying to grow throughout the, (51:58) throughout the United States. Well, let’s, are you ready to grow? How are you going to reach (52:03) markets that have a, a heavy, heavy, heavy Latinx population or Hispanic population, (52:09) you know, and, and your, are your folks that are engaging on the ground able to speak Spanish at (52:15) all? Are they, are they fluent in, in, in, in the cultural nuances of that and how to sell? And, (52:21) and so you’re, and so it’s like, well, what problem can I help solve? Right. Once you do that, (52:27) you get a leader’s attention.
I love it. Yeah. Take, take the small bites.
I’m sorry, April. IÂ (52:35)Â didn’t mean to say that. Yeah.
Small bites. We’re doing the A’s. We’re doing the A’s.
(52:42)Â Right there. That point right there. Okay.
So it sounds like based on the chat and everything, (52:47) we need to part two, but we just thank you all. Thank you again, everyone in the chat. Thank you (52:51) for your interaction.
If we did not, I try to acknowledge everyone’s comments. I mean, it was (52:56) on fire. This was so great.
I mean, it was so hot that my, my system muted on me. I had to refresh. (53:01) So thank you all continue to do the work.
Please follow all these ladies on LinkedIn. We have a (53:06) phenomenal rest. We have a few more sessions left.
So our next session is there’s two breakouts that (53:11) you can choose from. So please go to the lobby to check that out. Thank you again, Brenda, April, (53:17) Rachel.
I am so honored and I feel like I left the session better than I started. So again, (53:23) thank you all. And thank you for joining EMTRAIN’S People Leader 2024.
Let’s make 2025 the best year (53:29) ever. Yes. Are we going to dance? (53:39) All right.
Well, that was a fantastic session. So I just want to reiterate what Leesa said. We do (53:44) have two breakouts going on and just that start in just a few minutes.
One is from Laraine McKinnon (53:51) and Dr. Leann Pereira about some of the great work that we are doing with EMTRAIN’S Analytics (53:55) and what it can do for your business. Another one is with our fantastic client success manager, (54:00) Rachel Schade. She’ll be discussing how you can make the most of a compliance training rollout and (54:06) how to do it effectively.
Also, I want to point out that we do have a video networking opportunity (54:12) going on right now. It will be available for the next 10, 15 minutes or so. To get to that (54:20) video room, you go to the event homepage, community, discussions, and you can join that (54:26) video call.
It’s a little quiet in there. So if anybody wants to put some names to faces, (54:32) I encourage you to head over there. There’s also a chat that’s available for the entire conference (54:37) that is more permanent than those that are up during the actual talks.
So, yeah, explore the (54:45) room. We’ve got some resources available for download too. So, all right.
Again, thank you (54:52) all for hosting this great talk and enjoy the rest of the show. Bye.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives have long been seen as a way for companies to foster a more inclusive and productive work environment. However, in recent years, DEI efforts have encountered significant backlash, as corporate leaders and employees alike face the tension of culture wars, legal challenges, and economic uncertainty. Despite these challenges, DEI remains critical in an increasingly diverse workforce. The question is, how can companies rethink their DEI strategies to make them applicable to everyone? In this video, Learn from this dynamic panel of leaders who make inclusion and belonging their top priorities. Rachel Williams, Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer at The Motley Fool, Brenda Clegg, Equity and Community Engagement Officer at Chatham County North Carolina, and April Allen, Co-Founder and Partner of Allen Unger.Â
There’s little dispute that DEI has become a lightning rod for debate. Over the past few years, DEI programs have faced mounting opposition, particularly in the wake of cultural and political shifts. In some sectors, there’s a growing perception that DEI programs can be divisive or overemphasize differences instead of uniting employees. For companies invested in these programs, there’s a growing need to adapt to the current environment. Also while staying true to the spirit of DEI. Which creates fair and inclusive workplaces for all employees.
Adding complexity to the situation are legal challenges. Laws targeting DEI training and programs have been introduced in various states, creating additional uncertainty for corporate leaders. These legal hurdles can cause companies to rethink their DEI strategies. Ensuring they remain compliant while continuing to advance diversity and inclusion goals.
Moreover, in an era of corporate austerity, where organizations are scrutinizing budgets more than ever, DEI programs may be the first to face cuts. But rather than trimming these programs altogether, there may be opportunities to refocus them in different ways. Which can align more closely with the needs of the modern workforce.
The evolving landscape of DEI calls for a shift in how these strategies are framed. Leaders must move beyond the traditional understanding of DEI as a purely “top-down” initiative driven by HR policies or external consultants. Today’s DEI strategies need to be integrated into every level of the organization, woven into the fabric of day-to-day operations, and embedded in leadership practices.
Focus on how to communicate DEI programs effectively. While the push for diversity, equity, and inclusion remains vital, the messaging surrounding these initiatives needs to be tailored to resonate across different segments of the workforce. Emphasizing how DEI drives organizational success, enhances employee engagement, and fosters innovation can make these strategies more appealing and less controversial. Shifting the conversation from “tolerance” to “embracing diverse perspectives for business growth” can help bridge the gap between differing viewpoints within the organization.
Inclusion is one of the pillars of DEI, but the concept of inclusion has often been misunderstood. For many, inclusion has been equated with accommodating historically underrepresented groups. However, in a truly inclusive workplace, inclusion should extend to everyone—regardless of background, identity, or position. It’s about creating an environment where each employee feels valued, heard, and empowered to contribute, regardless of their differences.
Leaders can reframe inclusion by emphasizing its universal appeal. Rather than positioning DEI efforts as catering only to specific groups, organizations can promote inclusion as a workplace principle that benefits all employees. This shift not only helps reduce the backlash. But also fosters a more collaborative, open environment where employees see the direct benefits of these strategies.
To make inclusion truly relevant to everyone, DEI strategies must go beyond simply meeting quotas or fulfilling legal requirements. It involves creating spaces where employees from diverse backgrounds can thrive, work together seamlessly, and engage in open dialogue about their experiences. In practice, this could mean offering flexible work arrangements. Meaning accommodation for employees with different needs, mentoring opportunities, or ensuring that employees feel their contributions are valued.
As DEI strategies evolve, it’s essential to measure their effectiveness and ensure they adapt to the changing workplace dynamics. Here are some best practices for creating more effective DEI strategies:
As the backlash against DEI initiatives continues to grow in the current climate, leaders must rethink their approach. By focusing on relevant and applicable DEI strategies that benefit everyone in the organization, companies can navigate these challenges and continue to build inclusive workplaces. With a shift in messaging and a focus on universal inclusion, DEI strategies can remain a powerful force for change. Even in a rapidly evolving and often contentious environment.